Lesson 19: "Has" and "Have" — Teacher Guide
Core Linguistic Concepts & Pedagogy
• Number Concord: Has pairs with singular subjects (speaking of one); have pairs with plural subjects (speaking of more than one).
• Contrasting Pairs: The exercise explicitly contrasts singular vs plural noun pairs (A bird / Birds, An apple / Apples, A cow / Cows).
• Modern Interrogative Structure: Questions in contemporary standard English use auxiliary Does (singular: Does a cow have horns?) and Do (plural: Do cows have horns?) with base verb have.
| # |
Subject & Number |
Verb |
Full Sentence |
Concord, Article & Syntactic Analysis |
| 1. |
A bird (Singular) |
has |
A bird has claws. |
Singular subject with article "A". Verb has. Predicate noun plural "claws". Declarative sentence ends with (.). |
| 2. |
Birds (Plural) |
have |
Birds have claws. |
Plural subject with zero article. Verb have. Declarative sentence ends with (.). |
| 3. |
An apple (Singular) |
has |
An apple has a stem. |
Singular subject with article "An" (before vowel sound). Verb has. Direct object "a stem". Declarative sentence ends with (.). |
| 4. |
Apples (Plural) |
have |
Apples have stems. |
Plural subject with zero article. Verb have. Plural direct object "stems". Declarative sentence ends with (.). |
| 5. |
a cow (Singular) |
Does...have |
Does a cow have horns? |
Modern interrogative syntax: Auxiliary Does + singular subject a cow + base verb have. Capital "Does". Ends with (?). (Classical textbook inversion: Has a cow horns?). |
| 6. |
cows (Plural) |
Do...have |
Do cows have horns? |
Modern interrogative syntax: Auxiliary Do + plural subject cows + base verb have. Capital "Do". Ends with (?). (Classical textbook inversion: Have cows horns?). |
🗣 The "One vs More Than One" Principle
Have students chant aloud:
"One bird has... Many birds have...",
"One apple has... Many apples have...",
"Does one cow have...? Do many cows have...?" to internalize the rule auditorily.
✍️ Modern vs Classical Question Phrasing
Classical 19th-century readers inverted the main verb directly (
"Has a cow horns?" /
"Have cows horns?"). In contemporary standard English, questions with
have take auxiliary
Do / Does:
Does a cow have horns? and
Do cows have horns?
🔍 Articles Review ("A" vs "An")
Draw attention to line 1 vs line 3:
A bird (consonant sound /b/) versus
An apple (vowel sound /æ/). Review when to use
a and
an.
🌟 Penmanship & Neatness
Focus on proper spacing between words, letter proportion on ruled handwriting lines, and exact placement of punctuation marks (. and ?).
Pedagogical Standard
Aligned with Classical Trivium Grammar Stage & CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.L.1.1.C, L.1.1.J, L.1.2.B