Lesson 9: For-Name-Words (Living Pronouns) • First Book in Language
Lesson IX introduces the concept of the pronoun (“for-name-word”) through immediate contrast and necessity. Children easily notice the clumsy repetition of nouns (“The cat saw a rat. The cat ran after the rat”) and experience the natural relief and rhythm of English speech: “She ran after it.” Rather than burdening the young learner with grammatical gender, cases, or antecedent terminology, Charlotte Mason’s method builds intuitive mastery: these words simply stand in place of names.
| Textbook Model | Teacher Guiding Inquiries (Socratic Dialogue) | Ideal Child Discovery |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The cat saw a rat. 2. She ran after it. |
“What ran after the rat? What word takes the place of cat in line 2? What did she run after? Of what does it take the place?” | “The cat. She takes the place of cat. It takes the place of rat.” |
| 3. A dog saw the cat. 4. He ran after her. |
“What word takes the place of dog in the fourth line? Of what word does her take the place? What kind of words are cat, rat, dog? Then what do he, it, she, her stand for?” | “He replaces dog. Her replaces cat. Cat, rat, dog are name-words. So these words stand for name-words!” |
| 5. John speaks to his sister. 6. She comes to him. |
“What words do him, she, and his take the place of? What kind of words are they?” | “She is sister. Him and his are John. They are called for-name-words!” |
| # | Textbook Practice Frame | Accepted Model Solution | Grammar Focus • Referent |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | The cat saw a rat. [___] ran after [___]. | She ran after it. | She = cat • it = rat |
| 2. | A dog saw the cat. [___] ran after [___]. | He ran after her. | He = dog • her = cat |
| 3. | John speaks to his sister. [___] comes to [___]. | She comes to him. | She = sister • him = John |
| 4. | The boy found a bird’s nest. [___] looked into [___]. | He looked into it. | He = boy • it = nest |
| 5. | Lucy loves her little kitten. [___] gives milk to [___]. | She gives milk to it. (or him/her) | She = Lucy • it = kitten |
| 6. | Father called his good son John. [___] walks with [___]. | He walks with him. | He = Father • him = John |